Concierge medicine in Philadelphia (such as MDVIP, SignatureMD, PartnerMD, Jefferson Personalized Primary Care, or luxury groups like MD2) charges an annual retainer ($1,800 to $28,000) on top of billing your insurance for office visits and copays. Direct Primary Care (DPC) replaces insurance billing for primary care with one flat monthly fee. Fishtown Medicine uses the transparent DPC billing model ($500 a month, zero insurance billing for visits, zero copays) to deliver elevated primary care: a 200-patient panel cap, 60 to 120 minute diagnostic reviews, one internist covering primary care, preventive cardiology, metabolic health, hormones, and longevity, and direct specialist coordination across Penn, Jefferson, Temple, and Main Line Health.
At A Glance
| Feature | Traditional & Corporate Concierge (MDVIP, PartnerMD, Jefferson, MD2) | Basic Direct Primary Care (DPC) | Elevated Primary Care at Fishtown Medicine |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | $1,800 to $28,000 per year, plus visit copays and deductibles | $100 to $300 per month, flat | $500 per month, flat ($5,000/year) |
| Insurance | Bills your insurance plus a membership retainer | No insurance billed for primary care | No insurance billed for visits; keep insurance for labs, imaging, and specialists |
| Panel Size | 400 to 1,000 patients per doctor (50 at $28k luxury tier) | 400 to 800 patients per doctor | Capped at 200 patients |
| Visit Length | 20 to 45 minutes | 30 to 60 minutes | 60 to 120 minutes (no timer) |
| Clinical Scope | Traditional checkups and referral handoffs | Everyday family medicine and urgent care | Excellent fundamentals + world-class prevention (ApoB, Lp(a), CAC/CCTA, hormones, metabolic health, GLP-1s, longevity) |
| Specialist Coordination | Standard referral slip | Standard referral slip | Dr. Ash contacts Penn, Jefferson, Temple, and Main Line Health specialists directly |
What Is the Traditional Concierge Model?
Think country-club or franchise retainer medicine (MDVIP, SignatureMD, PartnerMD, hospital programs like Jefferson Personalized Primary Care, or luxury retainers like MD2). You pay an annual retainer ($1,800 to $28,000 per year) for a smaller panel and faster scheduling. Most hybrid concierge practices still code every visit, bill your insurance, collect copays, and stay inside insurance rules ("we cannot spend 90 minutes on prevention because insurance only reimburses a 20-minute coded visit").
What Is the Direct Primary Care (DPC) Model?
Direct Primary Care is a transparent billing structure: one flat monthly fee covers your physician's time and direct primary care, with zero insurance billing for visits and zero copays. Basic DPC clinics typically price between $100 and $250 a month and focus on everyday acute and family medicine (strep tests, blood pressure checks, routine refills) with panels of 400 to 800 patients.
What Is Elevated Primary Care at Fishtown Medicine?
Direct primary care is our billing model; what we deliver is elevated primary care built on excellent fundamentals and world-class prevention:
- Zero Double-Dipping (DPC Billing): We never bill insurance for our time, and you never pay a visit copay. You keep your regular health insurance for Quest and LabCorp bloodwork, imaging, prescriptions, hospital care, and Penn or Jefferson specialists.
- One Physician Across Every Lane: Most people have to piece their care together across a primary care office, a hormone clinic, a cardiologist for borderline numbers, a metabolic or weight program, and someone for mental health medication, with no one reading the whole story. At Fishtown Medicine, one board-certified internist covers those lanes in one place alongside everyday sick visits, rashes, UTIs, and refills.
- True Low-Volume Depth (200-Patient Cap): Because Dr. Ash caps his panel at 200 adults (compared with 600 in corporate concierge and 2,500 in standard care), visits have no timer (diagnostic and lab reviews run 60 to 120 minutes), you text him directly, and he coordinates directly with your specialists at Penn, Jefferson, Temple, and Main Line Health so you are never the messenger between your own doctors.
Why We Reject the "Sick Care" System
Both traditional concierge and basic DPC are often still reactive (waiting for you to get sick). We are proactive. We use the membership model to fund the time and technology needed to reduce disease risk earlier and build healthspan.
Fishtown Medicine
A 90-minute conversation with Dr. Ash. A written plan you can follow.
Actionable Steps for Philadelphians
Match the model to your goal.
- Define Your Goal: Faster access to a traditional checkup (corporate concierge), basic everyday primary care (standard DPC), or elevated primary care with deep prevention in one place (Fishtown Medicine)?
- Ask About Insurance Billing: Always ask, "Do you bill my insurance on top of the membership fee?" before joining any concierge practice.
- Check Panel Size: A panel capped at 200 patients gives your doctor far more time for your case than a 600-patient corporate concierge panel.
Scientific References
- Eskew PM, Klink K. Direct Primary Care: Practice Distribution and Cost Across the Nation. J Am Board Fam Med. 2015.
- Klemes A, et al. Personalized preventive care reduces hospitalization rates. Am J Manag Care. 2012.
- AMA Council on Medical Service. Direct Primary Care: An Innovative Alternative to Conventional Health Insurance. 2018.
Related at Fishtown Medicine
- Direct Primary Care in Philadelphia - what membership-based primary care looks like
- Concierge Medicine Cost - the numbers on concierge medicine in Philadelphia
- Compare Your Options - the side-by-side of every way to get care here
- What a Concierge Doctor in Philadelphia Gets You - what the label does and does not guarantee
Frequently Asked Questions
Common Questions
Deep-Dive Questions
Ready when you are
The chat is our AI assistant, answering from our published guides. To talk it through with Dr. Ash himself, start with the intake.




